Our Final (Thursday, Dec 13 from Noon to 1:50) will be a debate. Vox populi, vox Dei.

       Each 'resolved' will be somewhat different, centering on the three elements of the class and from that center, coming to terms (critique, corroboration or creative synthesis) with Huntington's Clash of Civilizations. For example, how does Just War Theory from the center of Israel, square with Huntington's ideas. (of course and as ever, feel free to be 'pro' or 'con' either the book or the position from the center.

     Each person will prepare a case and present it in about 2 minutes but less than 3 minutes, with a minute or so for response/rebuttal.

      Each person hands in at the end an outline of what you have prepared, and notes.

     The point is to pick a position as outlined below, then read and research to find how that particular position agrees, disagrees etc with various parts of the book, Clash of Civilizations. Then present that point with evidence. Scour our books, then the library's books, then all else.

      If you are in fundamental disagreement with Huntington, yet would like to present a positive position, rather than only attack the book, feel free to adopt some other intellectual framework, like Fukuyama's Liberalism.

So, Required for the Final:

  1. Present 2-3 minutes on your chosen theme/thesis (listed below) in a concise, direct, laconic, convincing, clear way.
  2. Make explicit reference to Huntington's book/ideas (either negative, positive or neither or both) and include reference to Osama's ideas, preferably his second Fatwa
  3. Present direct evidence of your case from primary sources and explain how that evidence relates and convinces
  4. Be prepared to defend your ideas if it comes to that in discussion.
  5. Be prepared to challenge other ideas with your informed background and courteous manner.
  6. Turn in an outline of your ideas along with notes separate or integrated into the outline
  7. If there is food, bring an appetite.

 

ISRAEL

Founding of: Amy

Just War: Brian

Yom Kippur War: Chris

Local Muslim -- Brooke

Zionist Joe

The Two-State Solution: Lynette

6-Day war -- Spencer

MUSLIMS

Iraqi Jail & Torture: Jessica

She'ite and/or Sunnite -- Lisa

Osama: Russell

Muslim Brotherhood : Britt

Ummah/Dar al-Islam -- McKay

Just War Pro: Robin/ Con:Matthew

Sharia Law: Martin

Jihad interpretations: Colin

WESTERN/CRUSADER

Evangelical/Anti-intellectual richard Hoffstadter: Julie

Daniel Yergin/Oil and foreign policy: Chris

Ideal(s) in Democracy Nissa

Techno-Modernity: Andrew